What Would Happen When I Shove A Creature Who Is Climbing Without A Climb Speed?

by ADMIN 81 views

Introduction

When it comes to combat in Dungeons & Dragons 5th edition, understanding the intricacies of movement and interaction between creatures is crucial. In this article, we will delve into the scenario of shoving a creature who is climbing without a climb speed. This situation can arise in various situations, such as when a creature is attempting to climb out of a well or a pit, and an opponent tries to disrupt their efforts.

Understanding Climb Speed

Before we dive into the specifics of shoving a creature who is climbing without a climb speed, it's essential to understand what climb speed means in the context of D&D 5e. Climb speed is a creature's ability to climb vertical surfaces, and it is typically measured in feet per round. Creatures with a climb speed can move up and down vertical surfaces without needing to make an ability check.

Forced Movement and Shoving

When a creature is climbing without a climb speed, they are essentially making an ability check to climb the surface. In this case, the creature is not using their climb speed, but rather relying on their ability score and proficiency to make the climb. Forced movement, as described in the D&D 5e rules, allows a creature to move a willing creature or an unwilling creature that is not incapacitated as a bonus action. However, when it comes to shoving a creature who is climbing without a climb speed, the rules become more complex.

Shoving a Creature Who is Climbing Without a Climb Speed

According to the D&D 5e rules, when a creature is forced to move, they can be pushed or pulled. However, when a creature is climbing without a climb speed, the rules regarding forced movement and shoving become more nuanced. In this case, the creature is not using their climb speed, but rather relying on their ability score and proficiency to make the climb.

When a creature is shoving a creature who is climbing without a climb speed, the following rules apply:

  • The creature being shoved must make a DC 15 Strength (Athletics) check to maintain their grip on the surface.
  • If the creature being shoved fails the check, they lose their grip and fall.
  • If the creature being shoved succeeds, they can continue to climb, but they are now at the mercy of the creature doing the shoving.

Example Scenario

Let's consider an example scenario to illustrate the rules in action. Imagine a ghoul is climbing out of a well, and a player character is trying to shove the ghoul back down. The ghoul does not have a climb speed, but it is making an ability check to climb the surface.

In this scenario, the player character can use their bonus action to force the ghoul to move. The ghoul must make a DC 15 Strength (Athletics) check to maintain its grip on the surface. If the ghoul fails the check, it loses its grip and falls. If the ghoul succeeds, it can continue to climb, but it is now at the mercy of the player character.

Conclusion

In conclusion, shoving a creature who is climbing without a climb speed is a complex scenario that requires a deep understanding of the D&D 5e rules. When a creature is forced to move, they can be pushed or pulled, but when a creature is climbing without a climb speed, the rules become more nuanced. By understanding the rules regarding forced movement and shoving, players can better navigate complex combat scenarios and make informed decisions about their actions.

Additional Tips and Considerations

When shoving a creature who is climbing without a climb speed, keep the following tips and considerations in mind:

  • Ability Checks: The creature being shoved must make a DC 15 Strength (Athletics) check to maintain their grip on the surface.
  • Fall Damage: If the creature being shoved loses its grip and falls, it takes falling damage.
  • Climb Speed: If the creature being shoved succeeds in maintaining its grip, it can continue to climb, but it is now at the mercy of the creature doing the shoving.
  • Combat Maneuvers: Shoving a creature who is climbing without a climb speed can be a useful combat maneuver, but it requires careful planning and execution.

Introduction

In our previous article, we explored the scenario of shoving a creature who is climbing without a climb speed. This complex situation can arise in various situations, such as when a creature is attempting to climb out of a well or a pit, and an opponent tries to disrupt their efforts. In this Q&A article, we will answer some of the most frequently asked questions about shoving a creature who is climbing without a climb speed.

Q: What happens if the creature being shoved fails the DC 15 Strength (Athletics) check?

A: If the creature being shoved fails the DC 15 Strength (Athletics) check, it loses its grip on the surface and falls. The creature takes falling damage, which is determined by the distance it falls.

Q: Can the creature being shoved use its climb speed to climb back up?

A: No, the creature being shoved cannot use its climb speed to climb back up. The creature is relying on its ability score and proficiency to make the climb, and it must make a new ability check to climb back up.

Q: Can the creature doing the shoving use its bonus action to force the creature being shoved to move again?

A: Yes, the creature doing the shoving can use its bonus action to force the creature being shoved to move again. However, the creature being shoved must make a new DC 15 Strength (Athletics) check to maintain its grip on the surface.

Q: What happens if the creature being shoved is knocked prone while being shoved?

A: If the creature being shoved is knocked prone while being shoved, it loses its grip on the surface and falls. The creature takes falling damage, which is determined by the distance it falls.

Q: Can the creature being shoved use its reaction to climb back up?

A: No, the creature being shoved cannot use its reaction to climb back up. The creature must make a new ability check to climb back up.

Q: What happens if the creature doing the shoving is incapacitated or unable to move?

A: If the creature doing the shoving is incapacitated or unable to move, the creature being shoved is no longer being shoved and can continue to climb.

Q: Can the creature being shoved use its climb speed to climb up a different surface?

A: No, the creature being shoved cannot use its climb speed to climb up a different surface. The creature is relying on its ability score and proficiency to make the climb, and it must make a new ability check to climb up a different surface.

Q: What happens if the creature being shoved is in a difficult terrain or hazardous environment?

A: If the creature being shoved is in a difficult terrain or hazardous environment, it must make a DC 15 Wisdom (Perception) check to navigate the terrain safely. If the creature fails the check, it takes damage or becomes incapacitated.

Conclusion

In conclusion, shoving a creature who is climbing without a climb speed is a complex scenario that requires a deep understanding of the D&D 5e rules. By answering these frequently asked questions, we hope to provide players with a better understanding of the rules and considerations involved in this scenario.

Additional Tips and Considerations

When shoving a creature who is climbing without a climb speed, keep the following tips and considerations in mind:

  • Ability Checks: The creature being shoved must make a DC 15 Strength (Athletics) check to maintain its grip on the surface.
  • Fall Damage: If the creature being shoved loses its grip and falls, it takes falling damage.
  • Climb Speed: If the creature being shoved succeeds in maintaining its grip, it can continue to climb, but it is now at the mercy of the creature doing the shoving.
  • Combat Maneuvers: Shoving a creature who is climbing without a climb speed can be a useful combat maneuver, but it requires careful planning and execution.

By understanding the rules and considerations outlined in this article, players can better navigate complex combat scenarios and make informed decisions about their actions.