What Is The Difference Between Rational Secret Sharing, Fair Secret Sharing?

What is the Difference Between Rational Secret Sharing and Fair Secret Sharing?

Secret sharing is a cryptographic technique used to divide a secret into multiple shares, which can be given to different participants. These shares can be used to reconstruct the original secret only when a certain number of participants collaborate. In this article, we will explore the differences between two types of secret sharing schemes: Rational Secret Sharing and Fair Secret Sharing.

Rational Secret Sharing is a type of secret sharing scheme that assumes participants are rational and selfish. In this scheme, participants are motivated to provide their shares truthfully in order to recover the secret. However, if a participant refuses to provide their share or provides a false share, the scheme fails to recover the secret.

Key Features of Rational Secret Sharing

• Rational Participants: Rational Secret Sharing assumes that participants are rational and selfish. They are motivated to provide their shares truthfully in order to recover the secret.
• Truthful Shares: In Rational Secret Sharing, participants are incentivized to provide truthful shares. If a participant refuses to provide their share or provides a false share, the scheme fails to recover the secret.
• Refusal-Resistant: Rational Secret Sharing is designed to be refusal-resistant. If a participant refuses to provide their share, the scheme fails to recover the secret.

Fair Secret Sharing is a type of secret sharing scheme that ensures fairness among participants. In this scheme, participants are guaranteed to receive a fair share of the secret, regardless of whether they provide their share or not.

Key Features of Fair Secret Sharing

• Fair Shares: Fair Secret Sharing ensures that participants receive a fair share of the secret. This means that each participant receives a share that is proportional to their contribution.
• No Refusal: In Fair Secret Sharing, participants are not incentivized to refuse to provide their share. Instead, they are guaranteed to receive a fair share of the secret.
• No False Shares: Fair Secret Sharing also ensures that participants do not provide false shares. This is because the scheme is designed to detect and prevent false shares.

Comparison of Rational Secret Sharing and Fair Secret Sharing

Advantages of Rational Secret Sharing

• Efficient: Rational Secret Sharing is an efficient scheme that requires minimal communication between participants.
• Secure: Rational Secret Sharing is a secure scheme that ensures the secrecy of the shared secret.
• Flexible: Rational Secret Sharing is a flexible scheme that can be used in a variety of applications.

Disadvantages of Rational Secret Sharing

• Assumes Rational Participants: Rational Secret Sharing assumes that participants are rational and selfish. This assumption may not always hold in real-world scenarios.
• Incentivizes Truthful Shares: Rational Secret Sharing incentivizes participants to provide truthful shares. However, this may not always be the case in real-world scenarios.
• No Guarantee of Fair Shares: Rational Secret Sharing does not guarantee fair shares to participants.

Advantages of Fair Secret Sharing

• Ensures Fair Shares: Fair Secret Sharing ensures that participants receive a fair share of the secret.
• No Refusal: Fair Secret Sharing ensures that participants do not refuse to provide their share.
• No False Shares: Fair Secret Sharing ensures that participants do not provide false shares.

Disadvantages of Fair Secret Sharing

• Complex: Fair Secret Sharing is a complex scheme that requires significant communication between participants.
• Insecure: Fair Secret Sharing is an insecure scheme that may not ensure the secrecy of the shared secret.
• Inflexible: Fair Secret Sharing is an inflexible scheme that may not be suitable for all applications.

In conclusion, Rational Secret Sharing and Fair Secret Sharing are two types of secret sharing schemes that have different features and advantages. Rational Secret Sharing assumes rational participants and incentivizes truthful shares, while Fair Secret Sharing ensures fair shares and no refusal or false shares. While Rational Secret Sharing is an efficient and secure scheme, it assumes rational participants and does not guarantee fair shares. On the other hand, Fair Secret Sharing is a complex and insecure scheme that ensures fair shares and no refusal or false shares. Ultimately, the choice between Rational Secret Sharing and Fair Secret Sharing depends on the specific requirements of the application.

Future work on Rational Secret Sharing and Fair Secret Sharing includes:

• Improving Efficiency: Improving the efficiency of Rational Secret Sharing and Fair Secret Sharing schemes.
• Enhancing Security: Enhancing the security of Rational Secret Sharing and Fair Secret Sharing schemes.
• Developing New Schemes: Developing new secret sharing schemes that combine the features of Rational Secret Sharing and Fair Secret Sharing.

• [1] Shamir, A. (1979). How to share a secret. Communications of the ACM, 22(11), 612-613.
• [2] Blakley, G. R. (1979). Safeguarding cryptographic keys. Proceedings of the 1979 AFIPS National Computer Conference, 48, 313-317.
• [3] Stinson, D. R. (2006). Cryptography: Theory and Practice. CRC Press.
• [4] Beimel, A. (1996). Secure schemes for secret sharing. Proceedings of the 1996 IEEE International Symposium on Information Theory, 108-117.