ProjectHook Resource Shows Replace Plan On Upstream Version V17.9.0
Describe What Happened
When running an upgrade test to v17.9.0 of the upstream provider, a replacement plan is generated for the ProjectHook resource. This unexpected behavior is observed when using the Pulumi GitLab provider.
Sample Program
The sample program that demonstrates this issue can be found in the Pulumi GitLab repository. The relevant code snippet is as follows:
// Pulumi.yaml
name: index_projecthook
runtime: yaml
description: A brief description of your project.
// Pulumi.yaml (continued)
onPrepare: |
pulumi config set gitlab:token $GITLAB_TOKEN
pulumi config set gitlab:project $GITLAB_PROJECT
// Pulumi.yaml (continued)
resources:
# ... other resources ...
my_gitlab_projecthook:
type: gitlab:index/projectHook:ProjectHook
properties:
confidentialIssuesEvents: true
confidentialNoteEvents: false
customWebhookTemplate: 'https://example.com/webhook-template'
deploymentEvents: false
description: 'My GitLab project hook'
enableSslVerification: true
hookId: '123456'
id: '78910112'
issuesEvents: true
jobEvents: true
mergeRequestsEvents: true
name: 'webhook-receiver'
noteEvents: true
pipelineEvents: true
project: '123456'
pushEvents: true
pushEventsBranchFilter: 'main'
releasesEvents: false
resourceAccessTokenEvents: false
tagPushEvents: true
token: 'secret'
url: 'https://webhook.receiver.endpoint/hooks/gitlab'
wikiPageEvents: true
Log Output
The log output for this issue is as follows:
pulumi:pulumi:Stack: (same)
[urn=urn:pulumi:test::index_projecthookaMXmFQCHn5dj::pulumi:pulumi:Stack::index_projecthookaMXmFQCHn5dj-test]
+-gitlab:index/projectHook:ProjectHook: (replace)
[id=123456:78910112]
[urn=urn:pulumi:test::index_projecthookaMXmFQCHn5dj::gitlab:index/projectHook:ProjectHook::my_gitlab_projecthook]
confidentialIssuesEvents : true
confidentialNoteEvents : false
+ customWebhookTemplate : output<string>
deploymentEvents : false
+ description : output<string>
enableSslVerification : true
~ hookId : 123456 => output<string>
~ id : "78910112:123456" => output<string>
issuesEvents : true
jobEvents : true
mergeRequestsEvents : true
name : "webhook-receiver"
noteEvents : true
pipelineEvents : true
project : "123456"
~ projectId : 123456 => output<string>
pushEvents : true
+ pushEventsBranchFilter : output<string>
releasesEvents : false
+ resourceAccessTokenEvents: false
tagPushEvents : true
token : [secret]
url : "https://webhook.receiver.endpoint/hooks/gitlab"
wikiPageEvents : true
Resources:
+-1 to replace
2 unchanged
Affected Resource(s)
The ProjectHook resource is affected by this issue.
Output of pulumi about
The output of pulumi about is as follows:
CLI
Version 3.153.1
Go Version go1.23.6
Go Compiler gc
Plugins
KIND NAME VERSION
resource gitlab unknown
language yaml 1.13.1
Host
OS darwin
Version 15.3.1
Arch arm64
This project is written in yaml
Current Stack: pulumi/index_projecthookaMXmFQCHn5dj/test
TYPE URN
pulumi:pulumi:Stack urn:pulumi:test::index_projecthookaMXmFQCHn5dj::pulumi:pulumi:Stack::index_projecthookaMXmFQCHn5dj-test
pulumi:providers:gitlab urn:pulumi:test::index_projecthookaMXmFQCHn5dj::pulumi:providers:gitlab::default
gitlab:index/project:Project urn:pulumi:test::index_projecthookaMXmFQCHn5dj::gitlab:index/project:Project::my_gitlab_project
gitlab:index/projectHook:ProjectHook urn:pulumi:test::index_projecthookaMXmFQCHn5dj::gitlab:index/projectHook:ProjectHook::my_gitlab_projecthook
Found no pending operations associated with pulumi/test
Backend
Name pulumi.com
URL https://app.pulumi.com/chall-pulumi-corp
User chall-pulumi-corp
Organizations chall-pulumi-corp, pulumi
Token type personal
Dependencies:
NAME VERSION
gitlab
Pulumi locates its logs in /var/folders/3b/6mr1jkqx7r797ff75k27jfjc0000gn/T/ by default
Additional Context
If you run with --refresh the replace plan goes away and the plan shows no diff.
Contributing
Q: What is the issue with the ProjectHook resource?
A: The issue is that when upgrading to v17.9.0 of the upstream provider, a replacement plan is generated for the ProjectHook resource. This unexpected behavior is observed when using the Pulumi GitLab provider.
Q: What is the expected behavior?
A: The expected behavior is that the ProjectHook resource should not show a replace plan when upgrading to v17.9.0 of the upstream provider.
Q: What is the sample program that demonstrates this issue?
A: The sample program that demonstrates this issue can be found in the Pulumi GitLab repository. The relevant code snippet is as follows:
// Pulumi.yaml
name: index_projecthook
runtime: yaml
description: A brief description of your project.
// Pulumi.yaml (continued)
onPrepare: |
pulumi config set gitlab:token $GITLAB_TOKEN
pulumi config set gitlab:project $GITLAB_PROJECT
// Pulumi.yaml (continued)
resources:
# ... other resources ...
my_gitlab_projecthook:
type: gitlab:index/projectHook:ProjectHook
properties:
confidentialIssuesEvents: true
confidentialNoteEvents: false
customWebhookTemplate: 'https://example.com/webhook-template'
deploymentEvents: false
description: 'My GitLab project hook'
enableSslVerification: true
hookId: '123456'
id: '78910112'
issuesEvents: true
jobEvents: true
mergeRequestsEvents: true
name: 'webhook-receiver'
noteEvents: true
pipelineEvents: true
project: '123456'
pushEvents: true
pushEventsBranchFilter: 'main'
releasesEvents: false
resourceAccessTokenEvents: false
tagPushEvents: true
token: 'secret'
url: 'https://webhook.receiver.endpoint/hooks/gitlab'
wikiPageEvents: true
Q: What is the log output for this issue?
A: The log output for this issue is as follows:
pulumi:pulumi:Stack: (same)
[urn=urn:pulumi:test::index_projecthookaMXmFQCHn5dj::pulumi:pulumi:Stack::index_projecthookaMXmFQCHn5dj-test]
+-gitlab:index/projectHook:ProjectHook: (replace)
[id=123456:78910112]
[urn=urn:pulumi:test::index_projecthookaMXmFQCHn5dj::gitlab:index/projectHook:ProjectHook::my_gitlab_projecthook]
confidentialIssuesEvents : true
confidentialNoteEvents : false
+ customWebhookTemplate : output<string>
deploymentEvents : false
+ description : output<string>
enableSslVerification : true
~ hookId : 123456 => output<string>
~ id : "78910112:123456" => output<string>
issuesEvents : true
jobEvents : true
mergeRequestsEvents : true
name : "webhook-receiver"
noteEvents : true
pipelineEvents : true
project : "123456"
~ projectId : 123456 => output<string>
pushEvents : true
+ pushEventsBranchFilter : output<string>
releasesEvents : false
+ resourceAccessTokenEvents: false
tagPushEvents : true
token : [secret]
url : "https://webhook.receiver.endpoint/hooks/gitlab"
wikiPageEvents : true
Resources:
+-1 to replace
2 unchanged
Q: What is the output of pulumi about?
A: The output of pulumi about is as follows:
CLI
Version 3.153.1
Go Version go1.23.6
Go Compiler gc
Plugins
KIND NAME VERSION
resource gitlab unknown
language yaml 1.13.1
Host
OS darwin
Version 15.3.1
Arch arm64
This project is written in yaml
Current Stack: pulumi/index_projecthookaMXmFQCHn5dj/test
TYPE URN
pulumi:pulumi:Stack urn:pulumi:test::index_projecthookaMXmFQCHn5dj::pulumi:pulumi:Stack::index_projecthookaMXmFQCHn5dj-test
pulumi:providers:gitlab urn:pulumi:test::index_projecthookaMXmFQCHn5dj::pulumi:providers:gitlab::default
gitlab:index/project:Project urn:pulumi:test::index_projecthookaMXmFQCHn5dj::gitlab:index/project:Project::my_gitlab_project
gitlab:index/projectHook:ProjectHook urn:pulumi:test::index_projecthookaMXmFQCHn5dj::gitlab:index/projectHook:ProjectHook::my_gitlab_projecthook
Found no pending operations associated with pulumi/test
Backend
Name pulumi.com
URL https://app.pulumi.com/chall-pulumi-corp
User chall-pulumi-corp
Organizations chall-pulumi-corp, pulumi
Token type personal
Dependencies:
NAME VERSION
gitlab
Pulumi locates its logs in /var/folders/3b/6mr1jkqx7r797ff75k27jfjc0000gn/T/ by default
Q: How can I contribute a fix for this issue?
A: To contribute a fix for this issue, leave a comment (and link to your pull request, if you've opened one already).